Vicarious liability in truck accidents

Liability claims are all about assigning who is to blame. In the case of truck accidents in San Antonio, that may seem fairly obvious: the truck driver. Yet given that driving their semi-trucks and tractor-trailers is a function of truckers' employment, one then might ask if the companies that employ them might be responsible, as well. In some cases, this may be a moot point, as some truckers operate as independent contractors who contract with motor carriers. Yet in those cases where a driver is employed by a carrier, the question should be asked in the wake of a collision

The legal principle of respondeat superior maintains that employers can be held responsible for the actions (even negligent actions) of their employees. Yet according to the Cornell Law School, there is no nationwide standard governing the application of this principle. It states that different states apply various testing methods to determine if respondeat superior is applicable to a case. One of these is the characteristics test, which rules that if an action is associated closely enough with the general duties of one's employment, then it is deemed to be a common characteristic of that job and thus part of an employer's expectations of an employee. 

Texas' stance on respondeat superior shows that it follows the characteristics test. A 2007 State Supreme Court ruling stated that “Under the theory of respondeat superior,...an employer may be vicariously liable for the negligent acts of its employee if the employee’s actions are within the course and scope of his employment.” Thus, if a truck accident occurs as a driver is in the process of completing a scheduled route, state law would allow accident victims to assign liability to the driver'ss employer. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

San Antonio Office
8207 Callaghan Road
Suite 250
San Antonio Office
San Antonio, TX 78230

Fax: 210-366-4791
Map & Directions

Lubbock Office
4920 S. Loop 289
Suite 103A
Lubbock Office
Lubbock, TX 79414

Fax: 806-780-4358
Map & Directions

Odessa Office
519 Golder Ave.
Odessa Office
Odessa, TX 79761

Fax: 432-362-4624
Map & Directions

Abilene Office
500 Chestnut Street
Suite 213
Abilene Office (By Appointment Only)
Abilene, TX 79602

Fax: 325-437-5786
Map & Directions